Your access to premium content.
USER NAME: 
PASSWORD: 
   • Register   • Info   • Help

Can private equity rescue home builders?

As home builders feel the credit squeeze, the search is on for their next source of capital

Mark Jarasek, Senior Editor
October 24, 2008
GIANTS

Sidebars:
Private Equity Deals That Have Gone Through
ADC Loans? Use Your Imagination.
Foreign and Sovereign Funds: A Capital Source?

“Realistically, capital has dried up for home builders,” says Jon Janecek, who specializes in real-estate transactions with the California-based law firm Newmeyer & Dillion. “Requirements have gotten tighter. It's like the early '90s.”

Janecek knows he's preaching to the choir. In the course of the current market downturn, home builders have watched traditional cash spigots go from a flow to a trickle to a painfully slow drip. Builders need cash for their projects, and an alternative source of capital may be emerging for them: private equity funds. It's not really a new source of capital for the wide world of real-estate; private equity has been fueling commercial, industrial and high-rise residential development for more than a decade. But it hasn't been until fairly recently that private equity funds have set their sites on home builders and the single-family residential arena.

Reports have been surfacing that massive amounts of private equity funds are being pulled together to take advantage of the opportunity that the free fall of home and land values is providing. At the time this article was prepared, sources interviewed indicated that the majority of funds out there are sitting on the sidelines.

“We know people have lined up equity commitments,” says Kelly Toole, partner in the Washington, D.C.-based Beers + Cutler accounting firm. “We're still at a point where they're waiting to jump in.”

Toole's observation is echoed by others. “We haven't seen a lot of activity yet, but that doesn't mean it doesn't exist,” said W. Hobson Hogan, an associate with the Raleigh, N.C.-based real-estate management consulting and investment banking firm FMI.

Risky Venture

Hogan cautions that due to the highly cyclical nature of home building, there may be a limit to the number of institutional investors and private equity players who will want to enter the home builder space. “They'd have concerns about catching the falling knife. There may be more interest in the home builders from those firms who are more opportunistic in their investment thesis, or contrarian investors or wealthy families or sovereign wealth,” Hogan says.

When these funds do come around, builders — as much as they want and need the cash to move forward with their developments — will want to be cautious. Private equity investors are not the same animal as the local community bank.

“There are different cultures. Builders are entrepreneurial. Financing people are bottom line. It's not like the good ol' days where things were done on trust,” Janecek says. “Finance people operate deal-by-deal. It's more black and white. Private equity firms are looking for a return, and there's a gap between what home builders have been used to and what these types of lenders are asking.

“There are controls and caps on the deals that are structured,” he said, citing the well-publicized cash infusion that Standard Pacific Corp. received earlier this year. “You have someone requesting a certain portion of the money you aren't used to giving up.”

Toole supports the notion. “You want to understand who your partner is and how they do business. You'll want to know their parameters — what are they going to want to see in terms of reporting? These private equity funds have a high level of sophistication. Builders might not be set up in their current accounting infrastructure to handle the demands of the private equity investors.”

Other pitfalls, Janecek says, include limitations. “There are limitations on contracts, limitations on other financing. At some point you want to know if you can regain control of your company. What are the exit strategies? What are the rights of redemption?”

More Than Cash

The primary benefit that home builders can expect from private equity is cash, Janecek points out.

But depending upon the private equity investor, other benefits can be gained for the home builder. “Not all private equity funds are created equal,” he says. “Some are financial engineers, others will have an operational bent, and they will come in to help the builder's management team formulate a strategy,” he says.

So exactly when might home builders expect to see private equity funds as a viable source of capital? “We are in a tough time,” Hogan says. “Yes, there will be deals, but at the end of the day, private equity is likely to sit on the sidelines until they feel there is a bottom.”

And when that happens, what is the best advice home builders can take away?

“Know the structure of what you are getting into and the length of time that will be involved, and what it does for your firm,” Janecek says. “Look for lawyers, accountants and advisors who can guide you along.”

 

Private Equity Deals That Have Gone Through

• Brookwood Value Partners, an affiliate of Brookwood Financial Partners, within the past few months closed on two major acquisitions in Florida. The first was the purchase of 214 finished residential lots in a community in Lehigh Acres, Fla., known as The Grove, from an affiliate of D.R. Horton. It is also contracted to purchase additional lots in that project at some point in the future. Thomas N. Trkla, Brookwood's chairman and CEO, says the firm believes the current dislocation in the housing market has provided opportunities to acquire residential lots at prices that will result in strong returns for patient investors. D.R. Horton will remain the exclusive builder in the project, and the company will buy the land back when it has a new home customer. Brookwood is a Massachussetts-based private equity firm that acquires real-estate and invests in private companies.

• In September, Brookwood Value Partners made its second purchase, closing on the acquisition of 106 single-family lots, 118 townhome lots and one commercial lot in Calusa Creek, a planned residential community in Punta Gorda, Fla. The lots were purchased from an affiliate of Beazer Homes USA. “Our strategy does not rest on simply purchasing lots at a discount to replacement cost,” says Thomas W. Brown, director of acquisitions for Brookwood. “You have to delve deeply into the local market and the type of product that will be the most in demand once housing comes back.”

• Also in September, Evergreen Real Estate Partners, a private real-estate equity fund managed by Chicago-based M3 Capital Partners, committed $750 million to Kitson & Partners, a Palm Beach Gardens, Fla.-based real-estate developer of residential and commercial real estate. Evergreen Real Estate Partners, capitalized with equity commitments of more than $1.5 billion, targets joint ventures with private real-estate operating companies.

• At the end of August, The Kolter Group, a Fla.-based real-estate development firm, announced a joint venture with Och-Ziff Real Estate Acquisitions where it will be seeking to acquire up to $1 billion of assets ranging from raw land to finished condominium units using equity and debt.

• In June, Detroit-based private home builder Lombardo Homes purchased all of Centex Homes' land assets in the Detroit market. The transaction was financed with private equity from an undisclosed local investor.

• In one of the highest profile private equity deals noted this year, Irvine, Calif.-based Standard Pacific Corp. received a $530 million investment from MatlinPatterson Global Advisors.


ADC Loans? Use Your Imagination.

Acquisition, development and construction (ADC) financing is viewed by lenders as a huge risk right now, Tony Avila told the home builder audience in attendance at the Professional Builder Benchmark and Avid Leadership Conference earlier this month. Avila is a senior advisor with Americrest Homes/Falcone Group. “You have to go and establish relationships with the little lenders who may not have current exposure to real estate,” he said.

Daniel Barnaba Jr., president of Syracuse N.Y.-based Eldan Homes, told builders at the conference that banks have been asking for equity up front, a situation he hasn't encountered before. “ADC loans have been very difficult to get from traditional sources,” said Barnaba, whose firm acts as a land developer as well as a home builder. “And when you can find it, you need to put a significant amount of equity into the project.”

Barnaba believes that venture capitalists could serve as an alternative source of financing for builders, “especially for land deals. The money is available, but [venture capitalists] typically want a higher rate of return than the banks.”

Also at the conference, Charles Sheron, chairman of Atlanta-based The Sheron Group, said although there still is liquidity in the marketplace, it's difficult to find because many banks are also in survival mode. “We're only limited to our imagination,” he reasoned. “Our industry has always come up with solutions and will do so again in this market.” 


Foreign and Sovereign Funds: A Capital Source?

Ernst & Young's 2008 Real Estate Market Outlook is predicting that the U.S. will be attracting “huge capital flows” from investors from countries such as Ireland, Sweden, France, Australia and others increasingly looking beyond their own borders for investments.

“It's the Canadian dollar's parity to the U.S. dollar that's bringing Canadian investors back to markets like Phoenix, San Francisco, Denver, Palm Springs and resort areas in Florida to buy single-family homes, condominiums and timeshares, mostly as second or vacation homes. Rapidly increasing oil prices are providing petrodollars to invest in U.S. and other real-estate markets for the first time since the late 1970s and early 1980s. The rise of the Islamic banking sector has also created additional demand for real-estate as an investment. A strong Euro and British pound are bringing European buyers back to both commercial and residential markets in droves.”

The Ernst & Young report makes this additional observation: “A rapidly emerging subset of the global capital wave is sovereign funds investing on behalf of national governments. Look for sovereign fund investors to potentially outdo their private equity rivals in the U.S. real-estate and emerging market investments. Look for some sovereign investors to seize the opportunity to focus on distressed assets and companies, particularly smaller and mid-sized home builders in the U.S.”


© 2009, Reed Business Information, a division of Reed Elsevier Inc. All Rights Reserved.

Talk Back

There are no comments posted for this article.

POST A COMMENT ON THIS ARTICLE


 

Advertisement